Dima Kornev
Newbie | Редактировать | Профиль | Сообщение | Цитировать | Сообщить модератору CMS Benchmark (Оригинал статьи по адресу - http://www.english.rk.edu.pl/article7.html ) Load time for CMS CMS name Load Time (s) Comparing with the slowest -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PHP Fusion-X3 3.05 0,3134 13,40% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- RkCMS Alfa-Alfa 0,316 13,53% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- GuppY (txt) 0,3299 14,10% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- jPortal 2.2.1 0,3381 14,46% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- jPortal Entropia 0,4001 17,11% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- LDU 603 0,4139 17,70% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Blue Dragon Platinum BETA 1 0,4249 18,17% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- jPortal Technet 0,4557 19,49% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- e107 0.615 0,4998 21,37% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Panda 0,6064 25,93% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Renegade 0.1.1 0,615 26,31% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PHP Nuke 7.1 0,697 29,55% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Agora Sunrise 8.0 0,6910 29,80% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Drupal 4.4 0,8051 34,43% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Renegade 0.1.0 0,8896 38,04% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MyPHPNuke 1,1114 47,53% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- E-Xoops 1.05 1,1237 48,05% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke 1,2218 52,24% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mambo 1,2408 53,06% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke 0.750 RC2 1,48 63,28% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Xoops 1,6390 70,08% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1,25FLS 1,8587 79,48% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1,30 Beta 1 1,9746 84,43% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Xaraya 2,0292 86,77% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro 1.06 2,3386 100,00% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke - MD-Pro - Envolution CMS name Load Time (s) Comparing with the slowest -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke (PNT Lite) 1,0641 45,50% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke (no blocks) 1,0949 46,82% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke (no referer) 1,1238 48,06% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Postnuke (0.726) 1,2984 55,52% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS (PNT Lite) 1,4140 60,46% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro (PNT Lite) 1,5679 67,05% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS (no blocks) 1,7592 75,22% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS (Encompass Lite) 1,7836 76,27% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS (no referer) 1,8313 78,31% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS 1,8587 79,48% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.25FLS (AT Lite) 1,9081 81,59% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Envolution 1.30 Beta 1 1,9746 84,43% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro (AT Lite) 2,0873 89,25% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro (no blocks) 2,1309 91,12% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro (no referer) 2,1827 93,33% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MD-Pro 1.06 2,3386 100,00% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Opisy testowanych instalacji CMSуw - LDU 603: standard instalation - Agora Sunrise 8.0: standard instalation - Blue Dragon Platinum BETA 1: 6 blocks + simple news with 1 news (Polish CMS) - Drupal 4,4: sstandard instalation + 2 news - e107 0,615: standard instalation + 4 blocks (poll, main menu, user menu, Online), no cache - jPortal entropia: standard instalation (Polish CMS) - Envolution 1,25FLS: standard instalation, 4 blocks: main, admin, poll, daily archives, Michelangelo Theme - Envolution 1,30 Beta 1: news on main page, Michelangelo Theme, 4 blocks: main, admin, poll, daily archives - E-Xoops: standard instalation - jPortal 2,2,1: standard instalation (polish CMS) - jPTechnet: standard instalation (polish CMS) - MD-Pro 1,06: standard instalation, 4 blocks: main menu, who is online, poll, daily archives - myPHPNuke: standard instalation - PHP-Nuke 7,1: standard instalation - PHP-Fusion X3: standard instalation - Postnuke: standard instalation, 4 blocks - Postnuke 0.750 RC2: standard instalation, 4 blocks, ExtraLite - Xaraya: standard instalation - Xoops: standard instalation, 1 news - Panda: standard instalation, 1 news (polish hack of PHP-Nuke) For Postnuke, Envo, MD-Pro - PNT Lite: Postnuke Extra Lite Theme - AT Lite: AT theme with AT Tags only - Encompass Lite: Encompass Theme with EN tags only - no referer: deinstaled Referer and Stat module, removed referer function and inlcude counter.php from pnAPI.php - no blocks: "no referer" + removed unused blocks from includes/blocks Comment The fastest CMS are those who are small like Fusion X-3 or LDU. Drupal is small but slow. PHP-Nuke looks quite good, which shows that he isnt slow and ugly CMS. In the Post Nuke family postnuke is winning. MD-Pro and Envolution use more advanced theme systems and they have bigger core. Envo is generally faster that MD-Pro but smarty template system slows him down. In the future winners will be those who wont use overgrown template systems, and those who dont make cms for all databases at once. But the biggest looser is Xaraya. Clean beta and she is one of the slowest CMS. Forums Test Forum Name Load Tile (s) Comparing with the slowest -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- EasyForum 2.1 (txt) 0,2878 14,69% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- punBB 0,2067 20,46% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- useBB 0,3037 21,59% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- QuickForum (txt) 0,3038 21,6% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Navboard (txt) 0,3221 22,90% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- txtForum 0.7.1 0,4101 29,16% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Invision Board 1.3 0,4161 29,58% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Invision Board 2.0 0,6032 42,89% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- phpBB2 0,9762 69,40% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PBLang 4.6 1,341 95,38% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- phpBB2 by Przemo 1,4065 100,00% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- All standard instalations. Comment Forum is for discussion, not for shiny add-ons like super signatures, shoutboxes, downloads, galleries etc. Competition have been won by the cleanest forum scripts, that dont have useless add-ons and features. Compare useBB with phpBB. In the test Ive put 2 forums on TXT files, and Navboard have won with smaller txtForum. Navboard is quite big and has generally all features that IVB or phpBB has. As for IVB the new release is much slower that last 1.3 ver… Testing Hardware and Software - Tests made on XAMPP 1.4 for Windows, on localhost - Apache 2.0.48, MySQL 4.0.17, PHP 4.3.4, Perl 5.8.2, Zend Engine v1.3.0 - Computer: 248MB RAM, Windows 98, Pentium 600MHz - Browser: Mozilla (Gecko) - Script (from the net): |